[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking

View post   
File: 236 KB, 1100x825, 5d44555936e03c05fe2fb6b6.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939471 No.14939471 [Reply] [Original]

There have been over 150 varieties of Oreo.

Which is definitively the best, /ck/?

Oreo knock-offs welcome, that adds another couple hundred competitors at least.
In fact bring them all, if it's prepackaged, has got two cookies on opposites sides of a cream filling, it's an Oreo competitor.

>> No.14939494
File: 74 KB, 610x458, 9DB6532D-A709-4BD7-AC62-74436751B3D6.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939494

/thread

>> No.14939500
File: 21 KB, 630x420, u15688_slide_34020.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939500

>>14939471
While not a particularly special, the best has always been Mint. Arriving originally in 1985, it had only a short life on the shelf before it was brought back in the early 2000s for a permanent stay.

>> No.14939508

>>14939471
The thin ones are best, classic flavor of course. What kind of absolute consoomer buys anything other than regular oreos

>> No.14939514

>>14939494
What is it about this variety that makes it stand out? The cream overpowers both the vanilla cookie and the chocolate cookie flavors, making it taste mostly like the cream filling. What's the point?

Both the original Oreo and golden Oreos taste better then heads or tails.

>> No.14939524
File: 58 KB, 1024x512, new_oreo_tease_main_004d99e506fe1c7a6479f657e5a19792.social_share_1024x768_scale.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939524

>>14939508
I agree that the addition of Oreo thin variety was a great addition. while I prefer the original amount of both cream and cookie, thins are still good, unlike double stuf which messes with everything and makes the whole fairly unappealing. For anyone unlucky enough to have pic related, It suffers an even worse ratio than double stuf.

>> No.14939536
File: 104 KB, 480x480, galleta-chocolate-macucas-arcor-123-gr1-5d4af5d1e7aa8166b815913753372769-480-0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939536

I don't like oreos but if the same type of cookies count this one is my favorite

>> No.14939567

>>14939536
They absolutely do. What is good about this cookie that you like, that oreos does not have and what is it about oreos that is unappealing? I'm willing to buy and try any cookie from anywhere to try it, I like cookies a lot.

>> No.14939586
File: 116 KB, 680x315, 1579429751793.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939586

>>14939471
>There have been over 150 varieties of Oreo.
>150 varieties of SOYreos
and every one of them fucking sucked they arent fucking oreos, theyre just oreo shaped cream filled cookies made by the company that makes oreos.
the only good oreos are the real ones, double stuffs and the old school hydrox bitches.
anything else is fucking soylent memery corporate faggotry to get fatties to buy shit they dont need.
all that said, the carrot cake ones were based but they were not oreos.

>> No.14939608

>>14939567
Macucas (that cookie) has more of a lemon taste in the filling that I like, the taste is not so cloying (if it the right word in English for that) oreos taste too sweet for me, the filling just feel like sugar not even like cream, it's pretty bland too in a way of that makes sense

>> No.14939638

>>14939586
If your argument is "only original oreo is oreo"
Then I'd expand my question to be "which cream filled cookies are best"?
Oreo has made over a hundred varieties of cream filled cookie. They are not all "chocolate cookie, cream filled," but they were made by the oreo brand.

Carrot cake was good, but not good enough to get again.

>>14939608
Thanks anon, that does sound worth trying. Just got a box, surprisingly cheap, even with shipping (8 USD total).

>> No.14939651

>>14939471
double stuff pls ty

>> No.14939664

>>14939471
Fuck oreos and their knock offs.

>> No.14939673
File: 1.93 MB, 1080x834, sub-buzz-592-1581013645-7.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939673

>>14939471
For me, it's Black Power

>> No.14939679

>>14939586
This is the fattest thing I've read all week.

>> No.14939697

>>14939673
I have never heard of this one, thank you anon.

>> No.14939723

>>14939638
Yeah it isn't an expensive cookie here neither and for you is even cheaper now that our coin is bleeding, enjoy them

>> No.14939755
File: 149 KB, 1280x720, muthafuckingelfcookies.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939755

>>14939471
>if it's prepackaged, has got two cookies on opposites sides of a cream filling, it's an Oreo competitor

This is it.

>> No.14939801

Bring back the thin pistachio ones, I haven't bought a single oreo out of protest since these stopped being sold

>> No.14939842

>>14939801
Never saw one of those but damn that sound tasty, probably the only oreos I could like

>> No.14939845

>>14939471
Hydrox. Oreos taste like chemical slop and leave a horrible aftertaste. I can barely put down one without gagging.

>> No.14939888

>>14939638
im just saying pink cookies with birthday cake filling is a fucking far cry from a real oreo and should be labeled as such
>>14939673
>eat the creamy white inside
>toss out the black cookie
some power

>> No.14939893

>>14939471
Classic and mint. Everything else tastes like chemicals

>> No.14939913

>>14939845
Here's a (you) because your comment obviously proves how special you are for not liking a more popular brand of cookie. Good job buddy.

>> No.14939931

The blueberry pie flavor was undoubtedly the best. The Oreo creme wizards somehow perfectly nailed blueberry without using any actual blueberry. It was sweet, but not to sweet, tart, and just the slightest hint of sour like an actual fucking blueberry. And they set it all on a graham cracker Oreo cookie.

BRING IT BACK NABISCO. BRING IT BACK.

>> No.14939936
File: 23 KB, 350x421, 6b718037ae9769ef0c4bfeced3829b8c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939936

>>14939471
Grabbed these (actually a different brand) from a pet store. Made for dogs and their owners to enjoy together. My dog hated them though.
I don't know if my mind was playing tricks on me and associating dark cookies with chocolate, but the carob cookies really did taste like nutty chocolate.

>> No.14939937
File: 363 KB, 1079x575, Screenshot_20201021-133953_Firefox.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14939937

Americans can't even begin to compete

>> No.14939941

>>14939524
The cream is literally flavorless whipped hydrogenated oil and hfcs. The cookie, however is pretty tasty. Which is why this are objectively better.

>> No.14939948

>>14939755
Based

>> No.14940159
File: 978 KB, 1200x1008, 575f0426651e0.image.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14940159

I feel bad for ya if you never got to try them. They are hands down the best cookie that comes in a package.

>> No.14940239
File: 49 KB, 569x439, 91wQpRgAYYL._SX569_.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14940239

These are amazing when you're stoned. Since I quit smoking though I don't even think I would touch Oreos, regular or otherwise

>> No.14940251

>>14940159
Fuck that does sound good

Their peanut butter and peanut butter chocolate pie flavors are pretty dope as well

>> No.14940648

>>14939494
>Mutt Flavor

>> No.14940652

>>14940648
Ok chud

>> No.14940680

>>14940652
Found the Oreo Double Stuffer

>> No.14940746

>>14939936
Shaggy is that you? Stop eating scooby's food

>> No.14940767

>>14939471
Banana cream was always the best

>> No.14940771

>>14940239
I came in here to post this. Probably the only Oreo flavor that's actually better than the original.

>> No.14941462

For all the ultra fats out there, this is great.

>>14939586
>>14939845
Hydrox is shit.

>> No.14941476

Unironically like trash off-brand oreos the best because they absorb milk like a motherfucker and get soft, whereas the real oreos are hard and hate milk

>> No.14941486

>>14941476
which off brand to do you like? there are quite a few that can give oreos a loss on blind tests.

>> No.14941506

>>14941486
Haven't had any in about 5 years so not sure. Look for ones that have a super opaque look to the cookie, since they tend to be made of a powder that absorbs liquid the best.

>> No.14941527

I'm a fatfuck and can't buy these or I'll eat then all in a day or too. When I go shopping I just skip this aisle...

>> No.14941530

they made a 4th of July "firecracker" one that was basically a regular oreo with red-and-blue poprocks in the cream, pretty neat to me. classic is hard to beat, there's something about the Oreo-brand-Oreo cookie that I think is unparalleled, there's a reason it's the classic cookies-n-cream cookie. some of these look nice though.
peanut butter never struck me quite right though, haven't had since I was a kid, but it always just made me itch for a classic oreo, same way a chocolate-flavored-cheesecake just blows out the cheesy flavor and makes me yearn for a classic slice.

>> No.14941532

>>14939471
Oreos turn my shit black I don't know what they put in it

>> No.14941550
File: 29 KB, 640x466, a5f.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14941550

>>14941530

>> No.14941570

>>14939638
>which cream filled cookies are best"?
I like this question better
that's easy, the maple leaf shaped ones with maple cream
what I hat about all the oreo flavored cookies is they are all double stuffed
fuck that, I like the cookie more than the cream
those carrot cake were were pretty rad, but mint is tops

>> No.14941594

>>14941550
boy HOWDY am I not immune to propaganda, I'm God's-own sucker and I'll fall for anything at least once. and we're living in a Golden-Age of the stuff, it weighs heavy on me.
now what makes you think to post that, though? the marketing of a jingoistic-holiday-oreo? or my pledge of allegiance to the oreo cookie and overuse of the word "classic"?
to note, when I say "oreo cookie" I mean the bread of the oreo-sandwich, as opposed to the oreo cream, which I can take or leave, but not referring to the-sandwich-as-a-whole

>> No.14941618

>>14941594
It was a schizo posting, I'm sorry if I made you seethe

>> No.14941625
File: 33 KB, 400x305, tsblr_oljedt1tdrmpo1t0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14941625

>>14939471

Back when they were made in USA and didn't have that granular creme like in the Mexican made ones.

>> No.14941839

>>14941618
calling my post schizoid, or saying that your own was? anyways nothing seething about me I didn't take any offense, just, any excuse to talk about my feelings. would you believe it hasn't been a most-sociable year?

>> No.14941877

>>14941839
It was my own, your post made me schizo rant, never met someone who liked the cookie more than the cream

>> No.14941902

>>14941877
never!
I mean granted, the cookie wouldn't be anything without the cream, the cream's the gimmick, the hook that gets you in the door, maybe I wouldn't like the cookie so much if it'd never been with the cream. but I don't see a major distinction in oreo-brand-oreo-cream compared to any other sandwich cookie, whereas, I've never had a chocolate-sandwich-cookie whose cookie stood up to The Real Deal Holyfield, I don't know what it is. There's something to it, I swear. It's not just some regular cookie.

>> No.14941948

>>14939931

That sounds amazing

>> No.14942037

>>14941570
Those maple cream cookies are superb. I pick one up whenever my local grocery store has it.

>> No.14942122

>>14939500
Canada gets very few fun flavors of things. The mint Oreos is one of the few that seems to stick around somewhat consistently. I'm happy it does. It's quite good.

Bring back Vanilla Coke you anti-leaf faggots.

>> No.14942139
File: 34 KB, 375x375, christie-collection-maple-leaf-cookie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14942139

>>14941570
Mint and Carrot weren't double stuffed from what I recall. Not all of the flavored ones are.

>> No.14942233
File: 178 KB, 374x376, 010.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14942233

>They discontinued the Birthday Cake Golden Oreos

>> No.14942566

I haven't had one of those in over 10 years.

>> No.14942681

>>14942233
They discontinued double stuf and mint oreos at different points and both made a return. you have to believe.

>> No.14943606
File: 39 KB, 979x370, Untitled.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14943606

>>14942139
>Mint and Carrot weren't double stuffed from what I recall
this is not the case. I just checked and both the mint and carrot cake weigh in at 14.5 grams per cookie at 70 calories
the regular oreos are 11.3 grams at 53.3 calories.
I've looked at the stores and I'm sure all the flavored ones are double stuff
pic related is the first amazon review for the mint ones
but thanks for posting the maple leafs. damn those are good

>> No.14943639
File: 294 KB, 1600x1200, RPBCO1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14943639

>>14939471
The best there ever was.

>> No.14943654

All these flavors and they never bothered to release just the cookie part baka

>> No.14943669

>>14943654
>just the cookie part baka
I'm not sure what baka means but I'm almost positive I would get these with my hospital meals for a night snack.
they did a lot of healthier alternatives and oreo has one that is just thin cookies with no cream
here's a link for you
https://www.warehouse115.com/nabisco-oreo-cookies-100-calorie-packs-0-81oz.html

>> No.14943739
File: 107 KB, 1000x500, oreo-thins-latte-1557774294.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14943739

>>14939471
For me it was these. Damn these were good, only got one pack but I savored them.

>> No.14943756

dark chocolate

>> No.14943758
File: 119 KB, 930x647, GoldenUhOhOreo.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14943758

>>14939500
Good, also Uh-Oh

>> No.14943771

>>14943669
>baked
Thanks for the heads up, though

>> No.14943914
File: 977 KB, 2390x2390, 003725002.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14943914

these are by far the tastiest sandwich cookie i've ever had. perfect amount of cinnamon and cream cheese flavor
>>14942139
maple leaf cookies are usually fucking great
>>14943739
its the thin lemons, for me

>> No.14943988

>>14940159
WTF I have to try this

>> No.14944091
File: 936 KB, 733x919, screen-shot-2017-03-29-at-2-15-01-pm-1490811250.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14944091

Fools, all of you...

>> No.14944493

This thread is making miss a lot of Oreos that no longer exist...