[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 125 KB, 422x342, Charlie.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16744686 No.16744686 [Reply] [Original]

Is Roger Scruton right about the Enlightenment being the soul of the west and postmodernism's danger to universal reason?

>> No.16744717

>>16744686
Postmodernism resembles early conservative critiques of Enlightenment-liberal-capitalist hubris. But what can you expect from a tobacco shill

>> No.16744719

>>16744686
Maybe

>> No.16744788

This is obvious but what's less obvious to many people is that Enlightenment has its own destruction built in. Demographics are destiny, and the kindest, most equitable society is paradoxically one in which a strong hegemonic race preaches Enlightenment but never really lives up to fully extending the franchise to various "oppressed" groups; life is best when this aspiration remains only an aspiration. The moment you actually reach Enlightenment's goals of giving every strumpet and nigger a voice, you get these exact same people tearing down your comfy Enlightened society by embracing racialism, opposing free speech etc. Turns out, their cries were a massive shit test and they only wanted power but what they actually plan to do with that power is ironically the same thing they whined white males did the entire time. See: America, and yurop soon.

God I love watching the decline of westoids, it is like some cosmic irony greater than any stage play. You really could not come up with this shit.

t. chink

>> No.16744810

>>16744788
Doesn't Asia depend on western consumption in exchange for western fiat money?

>> No.16744931

>>16744810
Asia depends on a lot of western things but when the apocalypse dust settles, Chinese people will still exist and move toward recovery. Meanwhile, Americans will be a warring stew of idiotic Brazil 2.0 mutts fit only to receive foreign aid.

Perhaps it had to happen. Liberals and internationalist leftists have pretty much destroyed any serious critique of demographic shift and policy implementation in the mind of the average person, but experiencing the consequences of their folly first hand and watching a Superpower get wiped out may serve as the perfect object lesson for future generations and finally make anti-racist retards shut the fuck up.

>> No.16745116

>>16744788
I see it as natural selection on a scale of societies. Liberal societies are perhaps more pleasant to live in, but what's happening in Europe has convinced me that no liberal society can survive against a religious one. They simply don't have enough kids to survive, and their acceptance of illiberal populations will be their downfall. Perhaps it's sad, but I guess it's the way of the world. The only way to avoid this is to go the China route (as far as I can see), and Westerners don't have the will to do that. I imagine the fall of Western society will be studied in the future as an example of the dangers of excess empathy.

>> No.16745136

>>16745116
Isn't china going to face a demographic crisis too though?

>> No.16745150

>>16744686
I haven't read anything by Scruton, where should I start?

>> No.16745153

>>16745136
Yes, which is a flaw in my thinking as well. I suppose no atheist society can survive in the long run.

>> No.16745158

>>16744931
Independent ethnic identity (and China has a ton of ethnicities) has actually been increasing rapidly in China despite radical attempts at engineering demographics and destroying all culture by the state. This means Chinese nationalism unsustainable.

>> No.16745165

>>16745136
China's recent affluence has the same consequences it has anywhere else, but it's a matter of time and scale. Europe is on the same track as America, but it's still so great because the cancer is nowhere near as advanced, and in China the tumor is smaller still, so that when you are destroyed China will just be a reasonably healthy hospital patient.

>> No.16745189

>>16745165
>We're doomed too, it'll just take longer
Truly an optimist

>> No.16745209

>>16745136
yes but they also have no ethical issues with shit like genetic manipulation of humans or artificial wombs.
If and when that can be done

>> No.16745222

>>16744788
>God I love watching the decline of westoids, it is like some cosmic irony greater than any stage play. You really could not come up with this shit.
lmao seethe harded Chang, even if your kind eventually invades and conquers the West your women will ALWAYS choose Caucasian men over Asian "men". give me that Chinese world hegemony right now, I've got to unload my BWC inside a tight yellow chink pussy

>> No.16745232

>>16744686
The west is more than two thousand years old. The enlightenment is three hundred years old. It is not the soul—it is the late-stage tumor.

>> No.16745236
File: 981 KB, 1377x884, Fertility.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16745236

>>16745136
The planet will be having a demographic crisis soon and people will realize you can't simply keep moving people to fill the gaps eternally.

>> No.16745256

>>16745189
Maybe you missed the part in my previous post about how we're not doomed because while the rot is here, we have avoided many of the same mistakes, and when the US goes under this will have quite a political impact. Many Americans, and later Europeans, who are forced to migrate east, if only to Russia and the like, will have their minds changed, and the remaining US with its feudal pockets of whites/wealthy mystery meat will face an awakening of their own like South Africa's. Meanwhile people here will be forced to take that into account, but who knows, that part is where it gets trickier. Still, I would bet quite a bit on brain drain from the US and Europe soon, and those migrants will find that the countries they are moving to are less hospitable to their liberalism.

>> No.16745259

>>16745236
I dunno. The population will drop a great deal, but I doubt it'll go to zero (barring an asteroid or something). Eventually, populations with a higher birthrate will become a bigger share of the overall population, and the world population will rise. Over time I expect the world population to float around some number much lower than today's.

>> No.16745326

>>16745256
>they are moving to are less hospitable to their liberalism.
Liberalism has a bad habit of overpowering its host country's views. If you guys manage to push it back, you will be the second nation to do so (the first atheist one as well).

>> No.16745391

>>16745326
We have survived worse. Ultimately my point was that we have a better chance because we haven't opened up our arteries in the bathtub like America so at least there's still a future and that's all you can hope for or reasonably predict. With any luck these demographic crises are also capitalism's own form of suicide, and then the Chinese one hundred years from now, if they are anything like us, may have something outside of current 20th/21st century paradigms, due to both ideological and technological advances. Hopefully they don't make it an even bigger fuck up lol

but history is fickle

>> No.16745414

>>16745256
Where would they go? Japan won't take on tens of millions of whites, and Westerners dont like living in China. They're not all just going to go to Russia. If you think 700 million white people are just going to abandon the West I think you're crazy. Eventually there will be a reckoning.

>> No.16745425

>>16745414
>Eventually there will be a reckoning.
hahaha

In Europe they've broken their backs bending over for Muslim immigration, you seriously think the masses are going to wake up someday and realize what's happening?

>> No.16745446

>>16745414
>700 million white people

They reproduce like dodo birds and not all will be able to migrate, just professionals fleeing the coop. It will just be small amounts of white people gradually moving over a period of time while American further brown-ifies.

>> No.16745484

>>16745446
>white white white
You guys love to say that whites are some superior race, but at the end of the day, they don't reproduce and they literally import populations to replace them. How on Earth are they superior? History will remember the modern whites as the single dumbest ethnicity to ever exist.

>> No.16745493

>>16745236
Many places are really overpopulated, I have been to the US and trust me Germany and Japan just feel very different in that regard. Once there are fewer people, they will breed more.

>> No.16745511

>>16745484
I never call them the superior race but they are viewed positively above many others all over the world for a good reason. If only they didn't have that pesky cuckold gene.

>> No.16745512

>>16745425
Perhaps you should more closely follow European political news.

>>16745446
You're still talking about tens, even hundreds of millions of people across the West. They're not all going to judt move to Russia.

>> No.16745546

>>16745512
nobody can predict the specifics but probably they will mostly move to europe first, then as that goes down the toilet, further east. meanwhile other countries will be rising economically for the same reasons. funny aside, actually the russian government is preparing for a wave of american and european immigrants if you believe RT shitposts.

>> No.16745562

>>16745512
>Perhaps you should more closely follow European political news.
The recent attacks are sad, but nothing will come out of them. People will seethe until some liberal rag complains about Islamophobia and things go back to normal. Meanwhile more Muslims move in.

>> No.16745724

>>16745546
Yeah again you're proposing that tens or even hundreds of millions of Westerners ultimately migrate to Russia. That sounds absurd.

>>16745562
The attacks are just one catalyst in a long list of many. You can look at Italy where the League is poised to take power next election as they lose ground to the direct successor party of the Italian Social Movement. In France Macrons centrist has essentially collapsed and he's forced to support increasingly nationalistic rhetoric to stop radicalized suburbanites from drifting to RN. In Spain you have the quasi-neofascist Vox making steady gains. I dont know what world you live in where Europe is already Islamized but its not a well-informed one.

>> No.16745735

>>16745724
I think you are mistaking saber-rattling for actual change. All of these parties could rise to power, and nothing would change.

>> No.16745742

>>16745414
Zapffe had an interesting perspective. Once a race becomes too self aware it begins to go extinct. Human consciousness has become too evolved in the white race, and like a species that has become too specialized it has begun the process of slow suicide. The human race should go extinct in my opinion.

>> No.16745749

>>16745735
Thats a pretty sweeping claim, whats it based on?

>> No.16745759
File: 241 KB, 374x373, lmao.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16745759

>>16745724
They will be moving, but not all of them to Russia. Not even just to Europe.

>absurd

Ah yes, documented white flight and economic pressures are definitely absurd compared to
>w-we're gonna rise up this time!

YOU.
AIN'T.
GOING.
TO.
DO.
SHIT.
WHITE.
BOI.

>> No.16745776

>>16745749
History. Conservative and liberal governments have risen and fallen in 1980s-to-now Europe, and no change has occurred to immigration. If anything, immigration has been accelerated, especially Muslim immigration. At this point, I consider all talks about anti-immigration policies to be paper tigers.

>> No.16745792
File: 163 KB, 1200x1192, alex jones.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16745792

>>16744686
The Enlightenment failed because it rejected the fundamentals of Aristotelian metaphysics, thereby allowing for a foundational crisis later down the road. I think it is not very surprising that the countries with the strongest beliefs in the fundamentals of natural law came out on top. And those countries are the United States and Great Britain. Now of course even their understanding of natural law is faulty and corrupted into the idea of natural human rights by way of Locke but it's still better than any political theory produced in continental Europe. Leo Strauss very well knew this.

>> No.16745820

>>16745759
You literally just said Americans would move to Europe and then they would all move east. They're not all just going to go to Russia and nobody is going to move to the Third World in order to escape Third Worldization. The fall of South Africa forced millions of whites to migrate and current day South Africa is still one of the leading nations of the Third World. When Europe supposedly falls apart and all of the tens of millions of professionals are trying to live in a country resembling what the West once was where ar ether going to move? Give me concrete answers instead of judt dancing around over the fact that you're wrong.

>> No.16745823

>>16745776
None of those parties I named are conservative or liberal...

>> No.16745863

>>16745823
They'll become run-of-the-mill conservative if they achieve power. I see all their statements as empty rhetoric, and I would be amazed if a single piece of legislation that was anti-immigration were to pass in any European nation.

>> No.16745880

>>16745823
>>16745863
Who cares? Conservatism is cope level relativism of yesterday's liberals. Rather you should embrace the fundamentals of Aristotelian metaphysics and become advocates of natural law theory.

>> No.16745899

>>16745484
>history will remember the modern whites as the single dumbest ethnicity to ever exist.
unironically true

>> No.16745904

>>16745880
I could care less which way Europe ends up. If anything, I'll look really stupid if Europe rejects Islam. I've been studying Arabic because I think that by 2040-50 it'll be the language of Europe and knowing it would give me a leg up in the future business world. If that doesn't happen I'll feel like a moron

>> No.16745908
File: 153 KB, 608x543, 1489894988684.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16745908

>>16744686
>soul
>west

>> No.16745915

>>16745863
>theyll take an ideological 180 because i say so! Also I don't follow any news anywhere in Europe
Good to know

>> No.16745930

>>16745820
They will move to countries where they will do better, simple as. In a few decades you may be better off ruling in Russia than serving in ameritmutt hell (especially if Russia can unfuck themselves away from a natural resources-based economy, stop sanctions, etc.) India, China, and many other countries are developing rapidly. Tick tock.

>> No.16745931

>>16745915
I'm telling you bro, nothing to stop immigration will happen. If you (I assume you're white) care about "preserving Europe", have 3+ kids. Everything else is a cope.

>> No.16745937
File: 54 KB, 500x616, wells.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16745937

>>16745915
>I'm going to fix my country by vooting for conservatives

ahahahahahahahahaha

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

>> No.16745938

>>16744686
lol no they are the reason the west is a shithole now

>> No.16745991

>>16745930
You can already move to China and get paid nearly double your salary because Chinese firms love skilled Westerners. Nobody fucking does it because you have to...live in China. I have never heard a Westerner say a single good thing about living in China, its a terrible place and not worth even a 100% pay raise. And India? Lmao not even Indians want to live in India. You have no idea what motivates these people and your theories are hilariously shit.

>> No.16746002

>>16745937
I think you replied to the wrong person

>> No.16746043

Why is no western nation internally liberal but Nazi tier on immigration? Its the only way to make it work.

>> No.16746081

>>16745991
>Nobody fucking does it

A lot of people do it and it's increasing lol, I am in Chinese construction and now we have more coming to work at American companies daily. It's the same in other industries and this trend will continue as cartoonish wealth disparity, political strife, and demographic shift all take a massive shit on the American Meme (formerly the American Meme) and similar in Europe, you are really not looking around and seeing what's happening to your own habitat. Previous middle class workers are now downwardly mobile and looking for a way out, plus nobody wants to live in a city where you can't walk outside safely past dark. I'm finally going to bed now but my dreams will be filled with your sweet cope, let me know how that voting works out for you buddy ;)

(t.b.h. I don't want to have such a rude tone in my posts but you are being very silly, good night burger friend)

>> No.16746122

>>16745930
your theory makes sense except for the location. i see whites moving south in groups. theres white towns in mexico already. why would people move all the way to europe? most middle class people cant afford that move in the first place.

>> No.16746471

>>16746081
>West will collapse without whites
PUH-lease. We'll continue making the West thrive even if all the Whites leave. The USA, France, and the UK will be stronger over time as "white guilt" ceases to be a matter of political importance.

>> No.16746507
File: 138 KB, 893x1360, 71cne2LETVL.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16746507

>>16745150
>I haven't read anything by Scruton, where should I start?
That depends on what you find interesting, he wrote over 50 books on multiple subjects, but my personal recommendations of his relatively short works are:

Beauty: A Very Short Introduction and his Why Beauty Matters documentary
https://b-ok.cc/book/2477316/8e98fa

https://vimeo.com/395449078

Conservatism: An Invitation to the Great Tradition
https://b-ok.cc/book/3525416/8dc193

Confessions of a Heretic: Selected Essays
https://b-ok.cc/book/3510149/7a535d

The Soul of the World
https://b-ok.cc/book/2459536/6d0fe3

>> No.16746916

>>16746507
Great post anon

>> No.16747799

>>16745908
t. tranny

>> No.16747806

>>16746043
Because the idea is contradictory.