Quantcast
[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / g / ic / jp / lit / sci / tg / vr ] [ index / top / reports / report a bug ] [ 4plebs / archived.moe / rbt ]

Maintenance is complete! We got more disk space.
Become a Patron!

/tg/ - Traditional Games


View post   

[ Toggle deleted replies ]
File: 56 KB, 265x370, Tibalt-the-Fiend-Blooded-Avacyn-Restored-Planeswalker.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]
40309802 No.40309802 [Reply] [Original] [4plebs] [archived.moe]

What's the worst planeswalker in each color?
Each multicolor?

Starting with the obvious.

>> No.40309824

From a crunch or fluff perspective?

>> No.40309860

>>40309824
Crunch more than fluff, but I'm intrigued on fluff.

>> No.40309872

>>40309802
Clearly you've never ulted him in a very, very busy Commander game.

That is something of the most utter beauty.

>> No.40309934

>>40309872
True, but that must have been a hell of a setup to make up for being down 4 cards.

>> No.40309944

>>40309872
Phyrexian rebirth is better.

>> No.40309952

>>40309860
Crunchwise: Original Ajani in white, original Nissa in green, Obby in black, no idea about blue, and you're right for red.

Fluffwise: Nahiri for white, Garruk for green, and the other answers are the same.

>> No.40310003

>>40309934
Down 4? His +1 is a flat +0 card advantage, and in some decks the discard can (emphasis on can) be beneficial.

>>40309944
I would certainly agree there. But there's something sort of artful about using every other player's commander to commander damage them to death.

>> No.40310266

Crunchways, Fedoracat, Elfhitler, Swampcunt, and Tibbles

>>40309872
I have a 5 color doubling season commander deck that is all about tutoring out doubling season and then making token copies of it through shenanigans. Even in the magic christmasland where I had 2+ doubing seasons on the field and could ult him intantly he was still underwhelming compared to every other planeswalker in my deck with only one doubling season out.

>> No.40310440

>>40310003
If you're at the point where you can ult Tibalt, you probably have better ways to win

>> No.40310641

While I'm here I guess I should say I'm asking for ideas for a Planechase variant, where one of the "Planes" is actually Planeswalkers. I'm open to other ideas.

>> No.40310697

>>40310266
>>40310440
Yes, I know he is hideously impractical. I don't simulate Tibalt as a practical wincon. I use him for hilarity in a non-competitive, rather casual format.

>> No.40310792

>>40309872
Or you could run Insurrection like every other deck that has red in it.

>>40309952
This, except Liliana of the Dark Realms for Black and probably Teferi, Temporal Archmage for blue.

And Teferi isn't really that bad, it's just him or Jace Memory Adept/Living Guildpact/Architect of Thought, and all of those cost less.

>> No.40310794

>>40310641
>where one of the "Planes" is actually Planeswalkers
wat

>> No.40310842

>>40310641
Not sure what you mean, but you could make running into a Planeswalker be a Phenomenon card and then have the effect something associated to that 'walker.

>> No.40310898

>>40310794
As in for one go round the kitchen table, a Planeswalker is the event. We're still hashing out whether it has loyalty or if we just roll a d6 or something to figure out what you can do with them. If it ends up being the latter case, two people could Insurrection in a row off of a Tibalt.

>> No.40310967

>>40310898
>Karn
This is a terrible idea.

On the other hand, I like >>40310842
>run into Teferi, gain an extra turn
>run into Jace, all your opponents mill N
>run into Ajani, gain some life
>run into Nissa, get an Eldrazi token
>run into Tibalt, roll Chaos until end of turn

>> No.40310988

>>40310967
>run into Sarkhan
>everyone loses to dragon rape

>> No.40311049

>>40310967
>>40310988
Exactly. Which is why I'm asking for low power walkers that could actually work here.

>> No.40311128

>>40310988
Now that I'm looking, Sarkhan the Mad wouldn't be OVERLY broken (there's a lack of actual dragon decks at the table for whatever reason).

>> No.40311231

>>40311128
True, but he was shit to begin with

>> No.40311283

>>40309802
Every time I look at Tibalt I think.
"If they just had decided to put something else than random discard as a negative"

>> No.40312989

>>40309952
>chandere is still asspained at Nahiri because she stole her husbando
I shouldn't be surprised

>> No.40313123

>>40312989
Sorin doesn't seem interested in Nahiri, except as a weapon against the Eldrazi. Although I am building a R/W Equipment deck to get sempai to notice me, just in case.
She's just a shit tier character with all her "EMOTIONS!!" and trying to turn characters with actual depth into generic moralfags just like herself.

I like the idea of Nahiri as yandere, but the canon just doesn't back it up.

>> No.40314029

>>40313123
I like the idea of you as shutting the fuck up, but your posting just doesn't back it up.

>> No.40314293

>>40309802
OG nissa is pretty shit. Baby jace is also overwhelmingly mediocre.

>> No.40314439

>>40309872
I don't play meme formats.

>> No.40314682

>>40314293
>Baby jace is also overwhelmingly mediocre.
It's the second or third best Jace, what are you talking about.

>> No.40314954

>>40314682
Thats fair, he just doesnt feel like he does much compared to some newer walkers i guess. I kinda feel bad for him, growing up in big daddy jace's shadow. Whos the wprst jace though.

>> No.40315641

>>40314954
>Whos the wprst jace though.
Living Tardpact
Then comes the dumb 5CMC mill jace.

>> No.40315915

Sarkhan Unbroken is the only Temur walker, therefore he is simultaneously the best and worst Temur walker

>> No.40316215

>>40309802
>draft box
>pull Tibalt
>throw him in for the hell of it
>win a game with his ult

Funniest shit.

>> No.40316263

>>40314439
he said commander, not modern

>> No.40319786

>>40315915
Same with most of the multicoloured walkers.

>> No.40322379
File: 126 KB, 720x480, 1390104086256.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] [report]
40322379

>>40314439
>Everything I don't like is a meme

>> No.40326219

>>40322379
Except he used the term meme correctly.

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Password [?]Password used for file deletion.
reCAPTCHA
Action