/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

>>3434431
>3430412

>>3434431
>>3430412

Usually best girl is the one who can sing. I guess when they can all sing, best girl is the one who can't.

>>3434431
And that's a GOOD thing.

Go to bed Kiara.

And still somehow the most charming one out of all of them

>>3434431
atleast it's fucking bearable.
one holo I can't hearing SOMETIMES is Noel, and others consider her singing soul.

>got btfod so hard in the ither thread he had to make his own

>>3434431

>>3434431
Ame is so much better now than her first karaoke

Ame is too cute when she sings!

>>3435110
Still worse than fucking Nyanners

>>3434431
And that's adorable

>>3434431
You're sorely mistaken if you think quality of singing is what determines the quality of a karaoke friend

>>3434431
>implying other holos don't sing boomer songs

>>3434431
Anon, Ame is tonedeaf and no one has the heart to tell her. Please anstand.

>>3435397
Nyanners is actually not bad desu, her songwriting is what's lacking. But she's fine when covering other songs.

Sorry you can't handle the SOUL

>>3434431
__________
__________
__________
__________
__________

>>3434639
That's some might fine logic you have there partner, Ill buy it

To all who find themselves in this thread pls refer to this

>>3436043
Fuck off you baseless non-members hater

>>3434431
You have no sense of SOUL

>>3436385
Either read that post or find some other bait

Remember that time Botan confessed she was not so much of a singer, only doing backing vocal on Blue Capper, taking her own time in order to debut a lo fi song, until the day she can hit some notes?
Or how about that time Okayu confessed that her low voice was not her idea of a idol pitch, getting away from the spotlight until proved otherwise?

Forget this. No need for modesty or self awareness in HOLOLIVE EN.
Just swear a lot and pander to some memes. That will do.

>>3437393
yes

>>3434431
>being a newfag
We've known this for months. But clearly, she's been practicing.

I mean. One of my memberships is Ame and I never watch any of her karaokes practice because the girl can’t sing. If she keeps trying maybe one day.

>>3437393
>No self awareness
She literally memed on herself after every song about how badly she sings

>>3437393
Yes, so?

>>3437393
and they can get away with it

>>3437618
>It could be worse!1!1!

It could be also a lot better. She is currently the worse singer in Hololive and yet she is doing a karaoke. What is that for?
I am not even hating on Ame, her reveal was top notch. But having some self awareness would not hurt.

>>3437393
t. never watched an Ame karaoke stream

>>3437667
Ironic shitposting still shitposting
Unless she wanna go full Coco and literally pander to reddit as full job

>>3437729
Then talk about shit we don't already know. FFS

>>3437729
Fuck you both, she's a rocket

>>3437861
Teamates be like
>we know our oshi is utter shit at singing but we demand you bring something new to the table
>this place isnt a board of free discusion
>you must talk about something else onegai

>>3437937
And they're right. Repeating the same thing like a parrot makes you a retard. At least add some rrat into it

>>3437937
Here's an update for you newfaggot. Ame improved. That's the bottom line. Now shut up.

>>3437926
I want Ame to sit on my rocket

OFFICIAL /vt/ SINGING TIER LIST

>S TIER
Azki, Gura, Mori, Sora

>A TIER
Moona, Risu, Kanata (start of career), Towa, Aki

>B TIER
Aqua, Matsuri, Kanata (half-deaf), Watame, Okayu, Roboco, Suisei (overrated), Shion, Nene

>C TIER
Ina, Kiara, Subaru, Korone, Marine, Rushia, FBK (in character), Mio, Miko, Mel, Ayame, Lamy, Flare

>D TIER
Luna, Haachama

>POWERGAP

>CHOCO TIER
Choco, Coco, Noel, Ame

>>3438055
>holoEN nigger
>calling anyone else a newfag
she sucks as much as she did in her birthday stream, cope and seethe for eternity gosling because anyone who isn't a GFE faggot can see she's still easily one of the worst holos in singing ability

>>3438055
ame had multiple bfs
get over it

>>3438149
>gura in S
>mori in S
stopped reading there

>>3434431
You're a LARPing EOP so you don't know this but Korone always sings boomer meme songs in her karaokes

>>3438149
Where the hell is Suisei on this list?

>>3438149
Worst list I've seen yet.

>>3438200
Three of Calli's songs are Hololive Top 10

>>3437729
>She is currently the worse singer in Hololive
Danchou...

Imagine going to singing and dancing classes weekly. Imagine hurting your knees to the point of surgery because you overdid it on your 3D stream. Imagine closing your stream because you got embarassed by hearing your own voice without BGM.

And then you have to witness all your effort being stomped by meme lords who have no clue about dancing, have no idea on how to hit notes, behave like trash and, on top of all that, are all terrible at videogames

Admit it guys. Holo En is a disgrace.

>>3438166
>she's still easily one of the worst holos in singing ability
And we're not arguing that. We all fucking know that she's bottom tier.

>>3438329
And Gura have more subscribers than Sora

Your point?

>>3438149
>O(overrated) TIER
Gura, Mori, your musical taste

>>3438473
imagine beign a faggot like you

>>3438024
So when she makes those horrid sounds do you expect people to ignore the shitshow?

Stupid faggot

>>3438526
>x is bad at y
>x still wanna do y
>people call it terrible
>HATERS

Literally Twitch gamergurl mindset

>>3438473
>meme lords who have no clue about dancing, have no idea on how to hit notes, behave like trash and, on top of all that, are all terrible at videogames
Youre projecting a bit too much there mate
I criticize ames singing because ive been singing for years and her disgraceful sounds are not normal, shes a lazy fuck that barely puts any efford into singing, not that this is bad but as a result she ends up sounding like dog being beaten to death on stream, nothing else to add

>>3438149
>S tier
>Calli

Oh yes, holo wigger. Peak idol perfomance.

>>3438902
cope

Ame cute

>>3438149
>S
>Mori
These niggers have such shit standards its unreal

>>3438837
That sounds like Coco reddit shitpost

>>3438149
Imagine putting Risu below Mori, let alone even CLOSE to her

Just imagine the third world subhuman that made this tierlist

>>3437393
You okay there Zhang? How's the learning of the English language coming along?

>>3439111
It depends if your watching her streams or not mainly karaoke, she knows whats songs her voices fits and whats not, Her technique is good specially for someone who hasnt had proper vocal lessons and stopped singing for a while (2 months ago) Now she's recieving proper lessons and its evident in her outfit reveal

>>3438149
wow you mean to tell me tons of people looked over this and thought "yeah this is OFFICIALLY accurate"? jesus the brain deterioration is faster than I thought check your ears people

>>3434431

Its not Ames fault that all music after the 90s was shitty autotuned hiphop trash that made P Diddys almost spoken word ripoff of Sting seem like Mozart by compairson

>>3438149
itt easily baited Teamates replying to this

>>3439158
Imagine ever listening to a treerat

Someone needs to archive this already so TeaMates stop latching on bait

>>3434431
She's trying her best, and she always does. It's a point of endearment that KFP won't understand.

>>3440348
In all honesty she probably believes shit singing is part of her gag

>>3440027
?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYzTq7YEPBI

>>3434431
calm down man

Based non-trained singer working the idol faggots

>>3434431
I actually like her for singing boomer songs, it's better than your modern shit songs

>>3437393
CHING CHONG BALA KALA BING BONG

>>3437729
Yes, it's called karaoke & not a concert for a reason. Go listen to Pop on Rocks if you want to hear how she sounds with a good editor.

>>3437729
>But having some self awareness would not hurt
She literally says she sucks every single karaoke stream, everybody knows it. She's having fun and has SOUL.
Atleast she isnt anime voice piercing us like Kiara

I'd honestly prefer if she just cut karaoke or did it less often but if you have any common sense you'd know the reason she's doing it is so she doesn't just utterly embarrass herself whenever the EN girls have to do idol stuff together.

>>3434925
But it IS soul

>Waah shes not singing 4 Yaosobi songs, King, and Useewa

Its karaoke, go watch Suisei or Kanata's live

Calli's voice is too deep.
Gura is just not fun.
And Amelia fucking butchers the song.

By process of elimination, only Kiara is the good one which I concur. She makes you feel happy singing.

>>3434639
You might just be on to something here. Noel is the best girl in JP and she can't sing either.

>>3438390
>checks Noel's singing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhOLeKa2Tio
Oh no no no
>Checks Ame's
https://youtu.be/PCTCnVrWSRg?t=21
They're honestly both so terrible. Like, worse than the average person. How?

>>3445220
Ame's Time after Time cover is enjoyable, its like your girlfriend is singing her heart out for you even though she sucks at singing. Ame is quintessential girl doing karaoke at a bar tier singing

>>3438149
>C-Tier
>Ina
Let's be real, Ina is not a good singer. She knows her limits and picks songs best suited to her. She is D tier.

>>3437393
So what are you implying? That people who can't sing well shouldn't sing at all? Ever considered that sometimes people just want to have fun and the world doesn't revolve around you and your ears?

also, YWNBJ

>>3438149
> mori in S
> Gura in S
> Susy in B
Shittastechama...

>>3438195
At the same time?!

>>3445220
This has to be on purpose right? I honestly find it hard to believe she's a part of an idol company and has definitely heard other members sing and yet she gives 0 effort. Not in a lazy way but as if she's a savant in not having singing ability. Just by hearing anyone with a decent voice you can pick up rudimentary singing skills if you tried.

>>3438149
If you're rating people based off of different metrics like "in character" or "start of career", than you have to put Kiara in a higher tier when she's not "in character".

>>3443922
>>3445963
https://youtu.be/aRIFtKuMqYc
https://youtu.be/S7-MIvJV8Oc
https://youtu.be/-rtAiXqv0A4
https://youtu.be/ipgQ7ZyyUMQ
https://youtu.be/82T8yOG5MTk
https://youtu.be/Wwcb7VNu4uA

>>3434431
my tone deaf wife's sex screams are disturbing and erotic

>policing singing

>>3446095
It's called being tone-deaf. More common than what you think.

>>3438149
>Gura and Mori S
go get your ear or brain checked

>>3452691
hi seething anti

Gachikois are mental and have blinders that make it impossible for them to accept that Ame's singing is only good in train wreck value.

>>3445270
Amazing choice of words, loser. Ame hates you.

>>3434431
Why did you memberfags lie to me? I thought you said she was getting good.

>>3456194
She is much better than before

>>3438149
>Gura in S
I disagree. She should be in SSS, Shiny Smily Story.

>>3456489
Being the second worse singer in hololive isn't an accomplishment.

I can't believe you faggots can't tell her bad singing is done on purpose, just check how her voice cracks, it's fake as fuck.
It's ok since it's part of her character, but please, get a pair a new ears before talking shit.

>>3457653
As long as she's getting better at it, it is

>>3438149
>Luna, Haachama

It might be an acquired taste, but you can't deny that Luna's a master at taking cutesy songs and making them 10x more cute. I often download her karaokes just for that.

Haachama's nothing special when she's singing in JP songs, but her unarchived English karaokes are all great just because of the unique flavor her aussie-JP accent puts onto it.

I would put them both up in B tier. Miko as well. The rest of these rankings I'm okay with.

>>3437393
Explain Noel then

>>3437729
>you have never gone to kareoke with friends

Anon... Your loneliness...

>>3445220
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T7Ql4D1UnQ
How does she do it?

>>3473520
i never believed that i was king until Noel sang it
pure magic

>>3438149
the best thing about this list is that my oshi polka is sparred from being in it
absolutely based

Everyone who criticizes Ame's singing I 100% guarantee is worse. You don't realize how bad you sound until you listen to yourself. Try it sometime!

>>3437729
Anon, if she wasn't self aware she wouldn't be making karaoke streams. She's fully aware she sucks, she's just fucking around, but retards like you think it's some sort of personal attack

>>3438149
>Mori and Sora in S
>Okayu in B
Mori sings subhuman rap garbage and Sora can't tune her voice for shit. Okayu has a sexy voice and sounds more like a professional singer than an idol, she should be at least A

>>3479262
surprised to see legitimate projecting here.

>>3438149
What is this retarded ass list

>>3438837

How many times does it have to be repeated before you comprehend? No one going to listen to it cares that it sounds like a trainwreck, especially when its improved from the multiple trainwreck it was in the beginning.

the fact that you need to repeat the same thing over and over despite it already being acknowledged and accepted instead of fucking off when clearly no one cares about that shows you need meds badly. Here, I'll prescribe you some.

>>3438149
>C tier
>Kiara
Is this bait? She’s an objectively terrible fucking singer.

>>3438149
>CHOCO TIER
My sides

>>3434431
Not every Holo has to be a singer you retard. That's why Hololive Gamers was a thing for a while. Fucking /mu/ reject.

>REMEMBER THAT TIME BOTAN CONFESSED SHE WAS NOT SO MUCH OF A SINGER, ONLY DOING BACKING VOCAL ON BLUE CAPPER, TAKING HER OWN TIME IN ORDER TO DEBUT A LO FI SONG, UNTIL THE DAY SHE CAN HIT SOME NOTES?
OR HOW ABOUT THAT TIME OKAYU CONFESSED THAT HER LOW VOICE WAS NOT HER IDEA OF A IDOL PITCH, GETTING AWAY FROM THE SPOTLIGHT UNTIL PROVED OTHERWISE?

>FORGET THIS. NO NEED FOR MODESTY OR SELF AWARENESS IN HOLOLIVE EN.
JUST SWEAR A LOT AND PANDER TO SOME MEMES. THAT WILL DO.

You are a fucking disgrace

>>3438473
How do you go on without killing yourself?

>>3438473
"I don't want these girls to have a personality. They have to be perfect singers and perfect gamers, and never miss a single note or button press."
Autism confirmed. You want to take the humanity out of people, and just coldly observe them robotically hitting all the marks on your checklist.
Cute girls playing poorly or trying their best in a soulful karaoke has its own charm and niche. You dumb faggot.

Amelia and Noel are literally my favorites for karaoke

>>3480680
I love her! as long as you keeps doing her reps, she will get better and better

Ame fags are deaf confirm , your oishi cant sing

>>3482676
what humanity? these people are getting money for putting almost no work in these things, you can say its envy yeah sure, but at least admit you dont care instead of decieving retarded kids with their parent money.

>>3486662
That's the appeal. It's like she's your gf on a karaoke date

>>3438149
>Okayu B tier
>Mori in S
Imagine being this much of a retard